Geo differentials don’t align to market data – Why Not?

Question: (original question from WorldatWork)

I have found that the geo-differential from Seattle might suggest that jobs, as a whole, in Seattle pay 10%-15% above the national market. However, when I ran a comparison of multiple surveys to identify the differential between the Seattle cuts and the National cuts, I found that the median differential, is much lower than the suggested geographic differential, overall.

  • Radford suggested that the Seattle cut vs the National cut had a median differential of only 1%
  • Culpepper suggested the Seattle cut vs the National cut had a median differential of about 7%

Is anybody able to provide some insight as to why these numbers are significantly less than what I have seen in terms of what the geographic differentials suggest?

Answer by Sam Reeve:

There are many factors that could lead to different geographic pay differential results between surveys.

Such as:

  • Different Data Sample.  Just about every survey out there will have a different group of companies that provide compensation data.  They may be from different industries, company sizes and some jobs may be more dominant than others.
  • Different Data Collection Methods.  Every survey has their own survey job descriptions and therefore companies will need to make a judgement call on how to match their roles to the survey.  In addition, not all companies provide quality information and it is difficult for survey companies to determine the good information from the bad.
  • Different Survey Methodology.  In school we learn the right way to use statistics and then some survey companies come up with their own creative spin on the science.  (I am not pointing any fingers here.)  Whether a company uses sound statistics or not, different survey methodologies with yield different results.
  • May have Different Definitions for Pay Elements.  Some survey companies may also define pay elements differently such as base pay versus fixed pay although, to my knowledge, this should not be an issue between Culpepper and Radford.  This is typically a concern with international surveys.

This doesn’t mean that surveys are all bad, it is just a fact that they are not a perfect representation of reality.  The bottom line is that the geographic differential process is inherently flawed.  It is not meant to be perfect.  It is meant to be a cheaper and less administratively burdensome than direct market mapping. (meaning, purchasing local surveys and mapping local jobs)  The key is to find the best source that works for your company and keep consistent with your methodology.  Understand that it is not perfect and check your employee attraction and turnover data to identify problems and adjust as needed.

You Pay Women TOO MUCH!

Stickman You Pay Women TOO MUCHSERIOUSLY. This was implied by a survey a client of mine recently completed. The survey, from a reputable organization that is dedicated to creating better workplaces and businesses, asked about a wide range of business practices including compensation. One of the questions focused on the pay differentials between male and female employees.

The topic was basically framed as follows.“Women at our company make the following compared to men: 0% – 25%, 25%+ – 50%, 50%+ – 75%, 75%+ – 100%.” You may immediately see the problem, or maybe not. No, it is not a lack of granularity. It is not a problem of Continue reading

Small Companies Deserve Compensation Excellence

Small Company Compensation-imageOften your HR person is also your benefits, recruitment, training, organizational development, problem resolution and party planning resource. Even though pay is just a small part of an HR professional’s expertise, your company should have access to the same experience and expertise as the larger companies you compete with. Why should your company be at a disadvantage?

Consider the following:

Liz, a CEO at a quickly growing company wants to make sure her company is paying its staff competitively. Her VP of HR / Office Manager, Tom, has been great at his job, but is swamped with other critical projects. Tom has also told Liz that he hasn’t had a ton of experience in dealing with compensation issues.

The company wants to pay its staff fairly. It also wants to make sure that pay levels are in line with the returns delivered to its owners and investors. There have also been rumblings that Continue reading

Pay Can’t Fix Anything! Fix it then Pay, Not the Other Way

Stickman Fix It FirstOften companies come to me with a request to design a compensation program, philosophy or market analysis hoping it will fix a critical problem in the company. Sometimes the company needs people to perform better. Sometimes they want employees to act and/or feel more like owners or investors. Let’s be clear, regardless of the issue, compensation CANNOT fix it, at least not in the long run.

Compensation can be effective at fixing (or hiding) problems for a short period. A bonus program to Continue reading

1 Versus 100 ($1M Vs. $100M)

1 versus 100-imageOn January 16, 2014 it was announced that Yahoo ended the employment of their COO and second in command, Henrique De Castro. Mr. De Castro was hired away from Google only 14 months earlier. His expertise in advertising was intended to be a major component in getting Yahoo back into a leadership position in this critical area.  In his year at Yahoo he made approximately $100,000,000. Even for the sky-high pay in the Silicon Valley, that’s not chump change. Continue reading

The Duckbilled Platypuses of Compensation

Stickman PlatypusMore than two years ago I wrote about “Defining Pay for a Compensation Unicorn”. A unicorn is a person with a skill set so specific and high level that it is hard to imagine them existing anywhere other than fantasy. Recently, some have referred to these people as “purple squirrels”. While the quest for these fantasy positions continues a more common person is the duckbilled platypus.

More than a unicorn, or even a hybrid, duckbilled platypus jobs combine skills so eclectic they won’t fit Continue reading

Global Expansion and the Importance of a Job Structure

Riding the Growth Curve

Several years ago, I worked for a company that was beginning to experience some significant growing pains brought on by its expansion into the global marketplace.  The young company I had joined had grown rapidly in the U.S. and was now looking for a stronger presence internationally.  Opportunities to open locations in Europe, Asia and Latin America had triggered a hiring phase unlike any the company had previously experienced and in the eagerness to expand; we overlooked the fact that we were rapidly outgrowing our own infrastructure.


It didn’t take long before the problems became apparent.  There was no process in place Continue reading

Compensation Archery: Aim for the Middle and Adjust as Required?

stickman archerArchery is an interesting sport. Great archers hit the center of the target nearly every shot. For those of you who have never shot a bow and arrow, you might be surprised that to hit the target you have to aim somewhere else. Sometimes you must adjust for the wind. Other times you must adjust for altitude. Even on the calmest days at sea level you need to aim higher than the target, just to account for gravity.

A key aspect of archery is that you perform in solitary manner.  You stand still, focused only on yourself and the target. Silence is the rule and Continue reading

Like The Auto Industry, Compensation Must Create More Hybrids

stickman hybridI read a recent article that discussed the annual Rotman Design Challenge. The competition pits teams from Design and MBA programs to determine the value of design methods in business problem solving. This got me to thinking about the eternal compensation debate of program design, versus business strategy (vs. communication.) The argument is whether design is more or less important than understanding the “business data” and whether both of these are trumped by communication. Continue reading

Follow the Leader is Dangerous, but So is Being the Leader

Stickman Follow the LeaderAs children, we play Follow the Leader with the goal of fitting in. In this game, kids will do whatever the person in front of them does. I have actually seen kids fall down, just because the person in front of them tripped and fell. As adults, we learn that to be a leader, you must worry less about fitting in and more about doing what is right for a given situation.

As compensation professionals, we are constantly asked to build a balance between two worlds: the Continue reading